Fresh 中文鲜货色 reviews

专辑乐评 : 飞轮海 — 双面飞轮海 , 棒棒堂 — 哪里怕 / 不棒也能飞


Photobucket

不棒也能飞

专辑:双面飞轮海
歌手:飞轮海
发行:华研

偶像的生命总是短暂,如果没有突破或长足的进步就会被淘汰。华研唱片当然深知这个道理,所以第二张的飞轮海,时间上相隔上一张好一段日子。成绩单是?

歌艺是有进步的,至少不至于难听。不知道是制作人的软件很会修还是他们真的下了苦功,许多歌唱技巧的处理确实听到较成熟的表现了。《新窝》的表现并没有输师姐太大,而且之前广告上听到这首歌的时候,还不知道是谁的歌,前面A段我还以为是吴克群。我想这样子说已经可以让他们很有面子了。

听得出这次收歌很认真,也很谨慎,远胜第一张。《不会爱》,《一万个快乐》,《爱的王道》,《出神入化》其实都算是不错的歌曲,他们的演绎也勉强过关,不至于摧毁创作人的努力。

找来超女刘力扬合唱 Ti Amo,更大的意图在于让这位华研新女生在亚洲区更多的曝光,而她也没有辜负这样的机会,表现自然势必胜过炎亚纶。

当然也有不好听的曲目,基本上没有提到的都可以随便听随便跳过。

对于偶像,要求会降低,但进步不能少。而且进步不只是艺人本身,唱片公司有没有用心挑歌也都是取分关键。

这张专辑值:6.5 条

我请你听《新窝》,《爱的王道》,《一万个快乐》,《出神入化》

一起听《出神入化》,然后再去听上一张的《不死之谜》就可以听见他们的进步。

Photobucket

专辑:哪里怕
歌手:棒棒堂
发行:Capitol

我喜欢风格一致的专辑,但一致的不好听不在范围之内。

如果一个团体六个人里有两个真的不能唱歌,三个属于路人水准,还有一个半职业水准的话,或许真的不能抱什么希望。

我不敢奢求他们唱得好,但是标杆一样,要听到值得鼓励的进步。
我可以接受像 Yes 这样的歌曲,但是也拜托制作人不要让这样的歌曲差不多/ 超过5分钟,感觉没完没了。《我们之间》亦是如此。其实他们平均年龄也已经过了20,所以过于稚气的演绎难免更凸显其窘境。

专辑最弱的一环除了我们心里有数的演绎之外,还有在收歌的部分。我不知道“小王子”是何许冒出来的人(也是那个引起抄袭风波的那位),竟然为棒棒堂写了四首歌曲,而且四首歌曲的素质还真的很有问题。

结果专辑最好听的歌曲正是我欣赏的阿弟仔创作的《我已经长大》。看来名牌不是盖的。专辑另外一首还能听的就是小煜创作的,有些接近英式摇滚的《Make me a fool 》。这位不只是真是假的rocker算是交出让人满意的作品,可是也同时让我想起以前在可米小子的王传一。我不是在指音乐方面这两位有一样的造化,而是他们都在自己属于的团体里显得格外有想法/不同。

如果有比较坚强的阵容,或许就不会出现这张听了也尴尬的专辑。虽然我从不迷信名牌,可是实力非常有限的歌手就偏偏需要这样的补强。如果就凭着这张专辑走进小巨蛋开唱,坦白说这可让多少其他线上实力派歌手情何以堪。毕竟小巨蛋演唱会是用来唱歌的,才艺只能用来加分的。

这张专辑值:4 条

我请你听《Make me a fool》,《我已经长大》,Yes

听最新主打 《哪里怕》。

明天:快乐帮,卢学睿

12則迴響

  1. xiaowangzi is also the person who composed 七彩棒棒堂。<br />
    我爱棒棒堂!hohohohohohoho!<br />
    LOL<br />
    and yahh,i like bbt but i know they cant sing.<br />
    矛盾LOR!
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:27 AM)

  2. can support their program lo, haha. but CD wise can just…wait<br />
    for the final gai ban then buy to keep can liaoz. haha.<br />
    <br />
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:27 AM)

  3. I kind of like these 2 groups due to their non-singing works like variety <br />
    show (lollipop) and drama series (fahrenheit) but for their latest albums, I <br />
    would give lollipop slightly higher ratings though both would still fail.<br />
    <br />
    Fahrenheit's album has too many 'old' works. If S.H.E. has songs in OSTs and <br />
    these songs are not in their full-length albums, then why is Fahrenheit <br />
    having so many 'old' songs in a supposedly new album? Speaking from a <br />
    consumer's point of view, they ought to have enough time to come out with <br />
    more new songs for this album since it had been more than a year since their <br />
    debut unless they really cannot find songs to suit themselves anymore.
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:27 AM)

  4. As for Lollipop, i only sampled few songs from legal website. not too bad <br />
    song choices. Problem with Lollipop is in their variety show, it seems that <br />
    they have been given the false impression by professional ppl that they are <br />
    quite good which apparently isn't the real case. For instance, 3 of them are <br />
    more involved in dancing or other 'talents' while the other 3 more on the <br />
    singing part. But out of those 3, I think only Xiao Yu can pull it off <br />
    eventually. Lollipop needs to know that self-inflation is definitely a <br />
    poison to their minds and it's high time for them to really work on their <br />
    singing if they want a slightly longer career in singing.
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  5. hmm i dont think quantity=quality leh. rather have jus a few new<br />
    songs of passable quality rather than a load of totally cmi ones<br />
    haha. sorry if i sound too biased against Lollipop but up till<br />
    now i still cant accept the mere fact of their existence, much<br />
    less to mention all the ridiculous privileges they enjoy( 2<br />
    albums and concert at 小巨蛋, wtf?!?!?!) lol..
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  6. 因为我是《模范棒棒堂》的粉丝,所以我买了。<br />
    their singing is _)(*&^%$%&*()(*&^%$#$%^&*(*&^$#@<br />
    but their song is radio friendly, so it sorta helps them lah.<br />
    their slow songs are killers,nic tunes but )*&^%$#@#$%^&*(*&^%$#@! voice.<br />
    <br />
    今晚将成立棒棒堂二军,希望如果[V]真的要这些男孩往歌唱方面发展,就请好好的选人选。<br />
    第一代的威廉是一个败笔。<br />
    其他人至少有才艺,就连只有样貌的王子算是棒棒堂里其中一个会唱歌的(虽然只是普通水准)<br />
    威廉虽然他很搞笑,但只会玩扯铃的人就要登上小巨蛋?!<br />
    很想知道当天的表现会是怎样的。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  7. 我可以铁口直断,他们会改版三次。<br />
    <br />
    第二版会送 MV , 第三版送小巨蛋演唱会精彩实录。哈哈,所以你还是<br />
    可以看到他们演唱会的表现。<br />
    <br />
    听说二军的人选其实已经知道了,听到有野兽哦。如果属实,那应该还有<br />
    一点听头。<br />
    <br />
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  8. Hei Se Hui haven't got 二军 out in the market yet, so fast BBT pushing 二军??<br />
    <br />
    My guess for 二军 (if still 6 people):<br />
    毛弟 (starting to shine as an individual)<br />
    小馬 (working very hard since the beginning of the show but lack the last <br />
    push)<br />
    野獸 (not bad a singer, just gotta work on personality, now too shy)<br />
    小祿 (supposedly not bad a singer too though i dun really find his singing <br />
    as good + got sis in Chn V)<br />
    李銓 (can see BBT trying very hard to push this guy, a bit like 威廉, a joke)<br />
    Momo (the only strong dancer for 二军)<br />
    <br />
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  9. 我指挥买一个版本而已,改版这种东西早就已经不吸引我了。<br />
    哈哈哈哈哈。<br />
    我觉得会是<br />
    <br />
    毛弟<br />
    小禄<br />
    野兽<br />
    <br />
    哈哈
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  10. <br />
    我本身也是節目的忠實觀眾,不是還有一連串的PK淘汰才選出二軍嗎?難道已經內定了?<br />
    <br />
    我比較希望阿本和TERRY入選,因為他們的努力和對節目的認真是有目共睹的。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:55:28 AM)

  11. No, I feel lollipop singing technique is better, <br />
    Farenheit has totally no singing techniques at all <br />
    except their looks.<br />
    <br />
    Rating for Lollipop album: B (not bad but can be <br />
    better)<br />
    <br />
    Recommended- make me a fool, wuo men zhi jian, meng <br />
    xiang lie che, yes
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:35 AM)

發表迴響

%d 位部落客按了讚: