繁体版
梁静茹《静茹&情歌》
发行：相信音乐
如果几行抒情的文案，还有几句不断重复的“我爱你”就是爱情，或许这次的制作团队低估了爱情。
这是所有梁静茹的专辑中，我最失望的一张。
摆明了《静茹&情歌》，以为会听见那些对于爱情更深刻的见解，更能唱进心底的情歌。结果是，完全没有。连一首情歌都不能，即便歌名是《情歌》也徒然无功。
《情歌》中段听起来很像《可惜不是你》，但后者的旋律徘徊不去。《别再为他流泪》如果是《分手快乐》的延续，那也只是一次更简单化的假设。劝解说的不费力气，因为也只不过是说了N次的老套安慰，模式Copy 得彻底，当然不费力气。
坦白说，连小寒老师作词的《用力抱着》也略嫌一般。少了以往的精辟，也体会不了“用力抱着”的复杂情绪，有些句子也觉得押韵的痕迹大于故事的流畅。但更有可能的是，曲本身已经不吸引人，就算有感动也会打折。
最失望的莫过于和曹格合作的“PK”。梁静茹+曹格这样的梦幻卡司，却只能交出如此中规中矩的作品，浪费了彼此的时间，也浪费了听众的时间。“PK”不是不好听，只是交给任何歌唱水平OK的男女歌手都能胜任，又何必劳驾两位。
专辑到了后段，开始显得混乱。《风笛手》听来格格不入，而即使我喜欢《不敢当》，但把摇滚摆在两首情歌中间实在失策。如果是紧接《没有如果》或许情绪连贯性会比较顺畅。《儿歌》这种很方文良类歌曲，一向来都很不合我的口味，自然不会打下好分数。
幸亏《属于》算是扳回一城，虽然明显跟着《崇拜》的模式走，但至少还能激起心中一点点的涟漪。刘沁的创作《找个人》虽然歌词普通得可以，但胜在编曲出色，慵懒的氛围听来舒服。虽然《没有如果》熟口熟脸但至少对梁静茹而言算是新鲜的尝试。参考若能比原曲好听，也是功力。庆幸《没有如果》做到了。
来到第十张大碟的梁静茹，真的遇到碰不着好歌的大瓶颈。这几年，相信音乐好像除了把五月天的专辑做好以外，似乎难以让我们真的相信音乐。
讽刺？那是现实。
我打5分
我请你听《没有如果》、《属于》、《找个人》
BY 老黄瓜
《没有如果》
商業化但卻能雅俗共賞<br />
<br />
梁靜茹真是一個特例
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:47 AM)
“相信音乐好像除了把五月天的专辑做好以外，似乎难以让我们真的相信音乐。”<br />
<br />
他们把钱炸在五月天的烟火秀上面了呀。<br />
真的很希望阿信能够再为fish创作，觉得他的创作每次都很适合梁静茹。<br />
超爱“燕尾蝶”。=D
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:47 AM)
Haha I dont think it is as bad as you made it sound like bah… Song-<br />
wise, this album is surely not as attractive & addictive as her <br />
previous (especially when Chong Bai was really a great success – in <br />
fact every song is worth it) but i thought Qing Ge and Ai Qing Zhi Suo <br />
Yi Wei Ai Qing are great attempts especially the former.. it brought <br />
back many nice and not so nice memories for me… I think Qing Ge is <br />
the best song in this album :)<br />
<br />
That being said, i feel that Yong Li Bao Zhe really sounds like a <br />
weaker version of Wo Men Jiu Dao Zhe (which itself is already weak <br />
enough). And the starting of Tian Deng really sounds like another song <br />
(which i forgot which one). I also agree with you that there's a <br />
serious problem with the sequencing of songs…<br />
<br />
It's not bad an album but when compared to Fish's previous ones, it is <br />
not as attractive… But seriously from 2008 December till now, only <br />
her album together with Joanna and Cheer's are worth listening… I <br />
rate the album around 7.5/10
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:47 AM)
I agree with Moses analysis and his comments. Mr Old Cucumber <br />
too "nasty" liao. Gave only 5 marks. Not say I too kind, this album I <br />
am going to give v high marks cos at least there is breakthrough. <br />
Sometimes singing too much ballads may be bored, Fish may have the <br />
choice or decision to sing other varieties of music, why can't? <br />
Seriously speaking, I only disappointed with her hit song mei you ru <br />
guo. <br />
<br />
Although her strength is at ballads; however, I like some of her new <br />
attempts in this album like zao ge ren and the qing kuai song feng di <br />
shou. Bu gan dang is another ballad rock song like yan wei die, makes <br />
me feel less "stressed" after listening.<br />
<br />
However, the most touching songs are of course her ballads which never <br />
dies! Below are my fav recommended ballad songs in d album:-<br />
<br />
<br />
Recommended:- qing ge, shu yu, yong li bao zhe, ai qing zhi shuo yi <br />
wei ai qing, tian deng, bie zai wei ta liu lei, er ge<br />
<br />
Final result:- 8.2/10 (Refer to U mag, about the same grading as mine)
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:47 AM)
I agree nowadays new albums v nice are mostly females like Joanna, <br />
Cheer and Fish. I am glad this yr more and more female singers are <br />
releasing albums. Finally the male singers get to "stand one side". Is <br />
always the male singers are more "popular". This yr, is female time! <br />
Jiayou! <br />
<br />
Also there is a china singer Jane teo (zhang liang yin) who release <br />
new album recently also not bad… the one (chao nu) who duet with Lee <br />
Hom's ling yi ge tian tang. her new R & B album is pretty <br />
impressive… can check it out!
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:47 AM)
to moses:<br />
其实最大的问题出在于，当你一个情歌天后到了第十张专辑，出了一张叫<br />
“静茹&情歌”的专辑时，理应我们应该听到超越前作的优秀情歌，才能符<br />
合专辑所标榜的。可是当词曲都无法达到预计的时候，那种失望真的会扣<br />
下很多分数。<br />
<br />
其实静茹还是唱的很好，只是歌曲真的收得不如以往。分数很多时候是和<br />
自己比，5分，就仿佛是最好的梁静茹的一半。<br />
<br />
to peter:<br />
是啊，我同意静茹需要突破。那些比较有突破的歌曲，我都有给予肯定。
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
老黄瓜 Says ：<br />
我不觉得我是 Nasty 。<br />
我们这里没有大爱精神，不喜欢的东西，没有必要假装喜欢。<br />
这个世界很简单的。<br />
给低分的时候，不赞同的都会跑出来，因为是低分。<br />
可又不见的打下高分时，大家记得。<br />
<br />
写好的，仿佛是应该。<br />
写不好的，就叫刻薄。<br />
<br />
这个世界哪里有那么多好东西。<br />
<br />
我们不追求和别人一样，但也不代表我们刻意特立独行。<br />
如果你问我们 Freshmusic 为什么可以看，那就是我们都忠于自己的想<br />
法，自己的直觉/听觉，而不是别人的 Copy。<br />
熟读老黄瓜乐评的，大概已经可以掌握到/猜到我喜欢听些什么，就好像<br />
也不难猜测九层塔等人喜欢些什么。<br />
<br />
You can don't buy that, but that doesn't mean we are bad.
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
我喜欢"别在为他流泪"!
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
我喜欢"别再为他流泪"!<br />
<br />
对不起,笔误
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
maybe the focus is not on “静茹&情歌", but "别在为他流泪"? since this <br />
album seems to move away from the usual emo and sad songs she usually <br />
do… haha.
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
just an add-on, i guess most listeners would have preferred fish to <br />
stick to her usual ballads instead, since that is her strongest area. ;D
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
to cucumber: <br />
<br />
nice one. and that's the reason I've been reading Freshmusic since <br />
2plus years ago.<br />
<br />
everyone has different comments towards things. not having the same <br />
sentiments as magazines or what doesnt mean anything, AT ALL.<br />
<br />
it just mean that, cucumber has a different liking?<br />
LOL.<br />
<br />
and seriously, her ballads are all the same. =="<br />
but shu yu is nice, ^5 cucumber!
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:48 AM)
lol, dont all ballads sound the same?<br />
<br />
but i must say that the qu feng of her new album is not as mainstream <br />
as before. maybe that's why it doesnt sound as nice as b4… summore <br />
she queen of ballad… naturally will have high expectations of her <br />
singing mainstream music.. haha.
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:49 AM)
我认为情歌绝大部分都是主流的，也包括所有收录在静茹这张专辑的。<br />
<br />
我只分感动或者不感动我而已
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:56:49 AM)
這張專輯讓我放棄梁靜茹<br />
<br />
我覺得比親親那張還不值得<br />
<br />
最喜歡的還是絲路跟崇拜
版主回覆：(11/04/2010 02:59:13 AM)