Fresh 中文鲜货色 reviews

专辑乐评:吴克群 MagiK 新歌 + 精选


Photobucket

繁体版
专辑:MagiK 新歌+精选
歌手:吴克群
发行:种子音乐

声势,运气说来就来,说走就走。《为你写诗》的吴克群气势仍在,信誓旦旦,没想到忽然间到了10月演唱会取消后,精选销量不好,人气也感觉大不如前。

真的没有原因吗?

这张新歌加精选当然旧曲都是一时之选,都是前几张成绩不俗的主打歌。

可是新歌是问题关键。

《爱太痛》完全比照以前的情歌模式来做,歌词又过度白烂直接,远远不及前作。《麦搁憨》的中文混台语听起来太刻意,而且还是跟《爱太痛》一样,太过熟口熟脸。《傻瓜》还是喜欢温岚和曾沛慈的版本。

最吓人的是找来过气女歌手王心凌合唱“Na Na Na”。这应该是今年最失败的合唱组合,完全无法为对方加分,反而是扣分再扣分。大家已经对王心凌毫无长进的甜蜜歌曲没有感觉了,而吴克群还打造更“恶心”的类似曲风,把自己的形象分数拉低。再加上编曲大退步,近乎到一无是处的地步。

想深情却沦为做作。想俏皮却感觉幼稚。

X X X

分数全部是赏给那些精选的部分。又偏偏家里已经有了这些专辑。感叹。

我打分:5

我请你听:精选旧歌,随便点都比新歌好听。

我很喜欢的刘虹华有参与这支 MV! 第二张专辑的第二波主打歌《别太温柔》。

8則迴響

  1. use to like him during the 《吴克群》,《大舌头》 <br />
    era,but after that i tot he was getting to <br />
    haughty,but his songs like 《将军令》was nice.<br />
    <br />
    but now……..<br />
    没有印象的歌曲。<br />
    <br />
    and yah.that nanana sucks.<br />
    TOTALLY.
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:27 AM)

  2. 听他唱《傻瓜》,我突然觉得,沛慈好会唱,而且温岚的版本更是无<br />
    可取代。<br />
    <br />
    听他唱《傻瓜》,我会很想砸掉电脑,因为这可恶的声音,怎么糟蹋<br />
    了自己创作的歌曲??<br />
    <br />
    听他唱《傻瓜》,我就惊觉,他或许还是应该专注在写芭乐歌给其他<br />
    的人…<br />
    <br />
    就够了。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:27 AM)

  3. I understand Kenji compilation new songs are not as <br />
    nice as his previous songs… Ai tai tong is chan fei <br />
    part 2, then mai tia gong is a "surprise" to me <br />
    leh… somehow "zhong guo R&B qu feng" but with "tai <br />
    yu", somehow a "breakthru" lah. But overall it comes <br />
    with a 20 song MTV so u can "kan dao shuang".<br />
    Yup yup I agree I prefer Landy ver of sa gua more and <br />
    the one from xing guang er ban which u mention. <br />
    There is one leng men song not in his compilation, <br />
    titled "zhi pian ren" in his 4th album jiang jun ling <br />
    and his 4th album is the most "breakthru" album.<br />
    I would give this compilation B+ and is one of my <br />
    most fav top 3 compilations of the yr. If u wanna <br />
    know d other 2, can email me. Thanks.
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:28 AM)

  4. Cyndi got one song da da da… now got one duet song <br />
    na na na… Next song wat ah? la la la or blah blah <br />
    blah? I think "ha ha ha" better. Ah ha <br />
    hahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:29 AM)

  5. 聽說他是票房太差才取消演唱會的,不知是否為真
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:30 AM)

  6. 哈哈<br />
    是的,这个传闻其实盛传已久。而且确实上网看购票系统,真的卖得不<br />
    好。不过照理说应该还是可以办1场的,所以之前原本减成1场,非常合<br />
    理,但是两场都 cancel 掉,是有点小惊讶。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:30 AM)

  7. ai yah sometimes cannot blame the singer lah, he got <br />
    no choice one that's why have to cancel the concert. <br />
    But I v pity him during his bday fall sick and <br />
    concert cancel… Hi yah… blame it on fate lor. I <br />
    knoe he is not on purpose one lah… He already got <br />
    this sickness long ago… So i think he should rest <br />
    more and health is more important… Anw he release <br />
    compilation after that maybe should take a break, <br />
    then can go "longer route" and give us surprises!
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:36 AM)

發表迴響

%d 位部落客按了讚: