Fresh 中文鲜货色 reviews

专辑乐评 : 朱孝天 Getting Real 新歌加精选


Photobucket
繁体版
朱孝天《Getting Real 新歌加精选》
发行:索尼音乐

我想,歌手也应该办道歉大会,对那些他所辜负的音乐人道歉。朱孝天请马上报名。

只出过1张专辑也能搞新歌加精选,首先唱片公司应该出来道歉。竟然能收到6首新歌加16首旧曲,我想不算精选,应该叫全选。

再来,6首新歌名单上有魏如昀、范晓萱、黄大炜、王雅君、小安等人,创作素质绝对不可能太低。听罢,难掩愤怒,根本是乱唱。《走出昨天》、《错了路》等等都是有一定情绪的歌曲,却被朱孝天唱的像诵经,吊唁亡魂般的毫无力气,如鬼丝一样。(还是在吊唁自己的歌唱生涯?)

黄大炜的“Rain”很轻盈的曲风,小安的《爱不停止》,朱孝天用他比无所谓更无所谓的方式来处理,连把音唱准都好像很懒,听起来常常都在Flat 的状况。是气功练太多哦?

旧曲部分反而还听得到昔日的朝气,但所谓的朝气也只是相对于现在的鬼丝。其实朱孝天理应是幸运的。《永不停止》是Skot Suyama (国外知名音乐人,有帮蔡旻佑做了不错的编曲)和柯有纶的作品,浓浓的Oasis 味道的Band Sound,如此可遇不可求的创作,也曾经被他一笔带过。

此外旧作还有阿信、毕国勇、李偲菘、李伟菘、李焯雄、伍佰、陶子、Tanya、陈珊妮、邬裕康、游鸿明、徐若瑄、易家扬!比黄金还黄金的阵容,结果都败在不够努力的朱孝天身上。任我们这些人怎么捶心肝也于事无补。

歌手因为自己天生声线薄弱,但至少有试着努力唱好一些,我都觉得还可以忍忍,但像朱孝天这类把一切看的理所当然,连努力的声音都听不见,实在气煞一堆更值得进入歌坛的好手。

分数?人家随便唱,就随便给咯。

朱孝天,你真的要鞠躬道歉。对歌迷、对创作人、还有对自己。

我打1分

我请你听“Inside of my guitar”

唯一唱的比较像样的歌:“Inside of my guitar” ,虽然音还是不准。囧。

8則迴響

  1. 朱君会告诉你,你不懂他的音乐。<br />
    <br />
    相信朱君还沉迷在刚出道的掌声里,可是他似乎始终不知道,大家好像是冲着组合里其他2人<br />
    的。与他无关。<br />
    <br />
    相信唱片公司没有罪,因为或许只和他签两张专辑的合约,所以还是随便发一发,让他走人,不<br />
    要浪费公司的资源。这其实是明智之举。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:56 AM)

  2. 唱片公司其实对他很不错,把这么强创作阵容找给他。这样的阵容绝对胜<br />
    过其他3子的创作阵容。<br />
    <br />
    可惜。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:56 AM)

  3. 除了有點驚訝沒別的…<br />
    <br />
    驚訝的是全選的事。
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:56 AM)

  4. 哇賽…我有SHOCK到<br />
    我雖然身為台灣人,可是卻沒有聽過他唱歌~~
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:57 AM)

  5. I only buy Ken's stuffs out of all F4 cos his voice is better and <br />
    clearer than the rest… especially in singing rock songs is his "na <br />
    shou". In Ken's 1st album is v nice… if u listen to the rest of the <br />
    F3, Zai zai vocal is v weak, Jerry yan ok but Vanness if sing too much <br />
    R&B ok but his hip hop song is too boring and some more the <br />
    pronunciation v unclear due to he's an ABC, so i feel that Ken is the <br />
    best singer out of the 4.
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:57 AM)

  6. But for this new song compilation album, looks like there are lesser <br />
    rock songs. The only rock song i can find is zou chu zuo tian and ai <br />
    bu ting zhi composed by Xiao an. The rest is either folk or ballad. <br />
    Zou chu zuo tian makes me think of Shino's wake up! Last album have <br />
    lots of famous composers' compositions like mayday, wu bai, chen san <br />
    ni, tanya, Weisong Sisong, You hong ming, ke you lun, vivian, tao jing <br />
    ying etc… but this compilation also quite similar except different <br />
    composers like wei ru yun, fan xiao xuan, huang da wei and xiao an <br />
    etc… My most fav in this compilation is chuo le lu, v touching and a <br />
    very K ballad. However, I still like the rock side of Ken Chu in the <br />
    1st album. But this new song compilation album is still ke quan ke <br />
    dian.<br />
    <br />
    Recommended:- chuo le lu, hao xin qing, ai bu ting zhi, zou chu zuo <br />
    tian<br />
    <br />
    Final result:- 7.2/10<br />
    <br />
    Topic:- Out of F4, who do u think sings the best?<br />
    <br />
    Hope to receive more posts or replies. thanks
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:56:57 AM)

  7. 翻著舊樂評看到這一篇….<br />
    他怎麼沒入圍最X男歌手咧?
    版主回覆:(11/04/2010 02:58:52 AM)

發表迴響

%d 位部落客按了讚: